Monday, March 8, 2010

Should Native Americans be forced to pay healthcare bills for people suffering from lung cancer due to smoking


Should Native Americans be forced to pay healthcare bills for people suffering from lung cancer due to smoking?
It was the Natives who introduced tobacco to the white man.
Politics - 13 Answers
Random Answers, Critics, Comments, Opinions :
1 :
sounds like a good idea, especially now that they make so much off casinos where people smoke like chimneys
2 :
Yes, if you are consistent with your logic.
3 :
They were just innocently trying to kill us to get us off their land. To bad for them that tobacco poisoning works so slow.
4 :
that's stupid, we didn't tell you to come here. besides who told you to inhale? even Clinton knew better. An old Indian chief sat in his hut on the reservation, smoking a ceremonial pipe and eyeing two US government officials sent to interview him. "Chief Two Eagles," asked one official, "you have observed the white man for 90 years. You've seen his wars and his material wealth. You've seen his progress, and the damage he's done." The chief nodded in agreement. The official continued, "Considering all these events, in your opinion, where did the white man go wrong?" The chief stared at the government officials for over a minute and then calmly replied, "When white man found the land, Indians were running it. No taxes, no debt, plenty buffalo, plenty beaver, women did all the work, medicine man free, Indian man spent all day hunting and fishing, all night having sex." Then the chief leaned back and smiled, "White man dumb enough to think he could improve system like that.
5 :
sure,,,,problem is the government has to give them the money to pay it.......
6 :
I like that idea
7 :
What tribe? Then who will the black men dying of lung cancer due to smoking sue, the white man? And which white man, the German, English, Finnish, etc.?
8 :
NO!!! I believe all people everywhere should be responsable for their own actions.
9 :
Wait!!!! I'm a native American and white! I was born in this country, served this country, paid taxes, and all the other good things that go along with that!! Not on drop of indian in me! If that's what your referring to? I have never went for this political correct crap, so call them what they are. Indians!! Or if you get down to it. They came to this country from Asia!!! They are no more native to America than Tokyo Rose! Even though they make millions if not billions each year of the evil white mans wampum, and can afford to pay it. I'm responsible for my health! WOW! Have you ever seen so many &@$#!*% out there!!
10 :
So if we follow that lil insane kind of thinking, WE the NDN's can sue you people for bringing refined sugar, flour and all the junk that has given us Diabetes. And all the diseases that plague this place because "pre-white man" we weren't sick with everything. How bout suing you for all the drugs that has came into this place since your "forefathers" came here. hmmmm and if you wanna get all technical about it, not every tribe used tobacco....and we sure the hell didn't have things handy like strychnine and crap like that to add to it. grow up and quit hatin.
11 :
They are now saying that alot of people are getting lung cancer and dont realize its from exspestos, the CDC is saying 1 out of 3 people have developed lung cancer from exspestos (airborne pathogen). I know for a fact there companies helping to get a settlement for anyone with lung cancer. My aunt had lung cancer and found out it was caused by a infestation in her house and won her case she was paid like 140 grand. They tried to settle out of court but she took 'em for everything.. anyway here is the company's site that is doing it http://www.lung-cancer-compensation.tk hope that helped:)
12 :
we aren't the ones that put cancer causing chemicals in the tobacco. and do you really want to open that can of worms where a race of people is held financially responsible for all the wrongs their race has done over the course of history? white people would be paying forever if that were the case.
13 :
really, hony? what about smallpox for just one example? what about systematic oppression over the last 300 years? but most importantly, WHAT ABOUT CHOCOLATE? they 'gave' us that, too. you assume that the indians gave the tobacco, but history shows that europeans were much more likely to simply take what they wanted.



Read more discussions :